Cape Coral Metro Foreclosure Attorney Guide
Menu

Martin Law Firm, P.L.

Updated 2026-09-27 · 3,170 reviewed · 116 listed · Scored from 183 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.4(183) 75 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified
Debt Collection & Consumer DefenseReal Estate & Property LawFree ConsultationBankruptcy Law (Chapter 7 & 13)Foreclosure Defense Litigation
Martin Law Firm, P.L.
Location
Caloosahatchee, Cape Coral
Services
Debt Collection & Consumer Defense, Real Estate & Property Law, Free Consultation
Reviews
183
Ranking
#9 in Debt Collection & Consumer Defense
Best for
Clients seeking family law or estate work with named attorneys Dustin Butler or Eviana Martin.

Google Business Profile is the source for the business data shown here, last checked 2026-09-27. Details taken from their website were fetched 2026-08-27.

What reviewers think

Reviewers with positive experiences praise individual attorneys like Dustin Butler and Eviana Martin for their knowledge, speed, and clear guidance through complex legal problems. Clients report feeling heard and achieving strong results in family law, estate matters, and civil litigation.

However, a meaningful minority felt abandoned by the same firm. Some describe unresponsive communication after billing, failure to file promised motions, and attorney turnover that left them frustrated. One client spent $9k without resolution; another faced delayed visitation paperwork that altered custody arrangements. Quality appears to hinge on which attorney you draw.

Praised for
  • skilled staff (Dustin Butler, Eviana Martin, Jonathan Bierfeld)
  • fast problem-solving and quick response
  • transparent communication and guidance
  • warm and personable
  • effective courtroom outcomes
Watch-outs
  • inconsistent attorney quality within firm
  • failure to follow through on promised actions
  • unresponsive to client follow-up
  • unfair billing and refund denial
  • condescending or dismissive demeanor
knowledgeableresponsive-communicationprofessional-stafftransparent-feespoor-communicationhard-to-reachunresponsive
Best for: Clients seeking family law or estate work with named attorneys Dustin Butler or Eviana Martin.
Think twice if: Ask upfront which attorney will handle your case. Some reviewers report unresponsive follow-up and billing disputes after initial work.

Strengths

  • Named attorneys with strong individual reputations (Dustin Butler, Eviana Martin, Jonathan Bierfeld)
  • Handles multiple practice areas from bankruptcy to estate litigation
  • Service area spans Cape Coral, Fort Myers, Naples

Worth knowing

  • Dustin Butler: praised for family law expertise and transparency; also complained about in unrelated case for unsubmitted motions and poor follow-up
  • Eviana Martin: repeatedly praised for estate and personal injury work
  • Jonathan Bierfeld: praised for fast problem-solving and complex matter resolution; also complained about for condescending demeanor
  • Matthew Stauffer: praised in two recent reviews for estate litigation and custody cases; criticized in one review for sloppy file review and dropped case after $9k billing
  • Kelly Arroyo: noted as senior paralegal praised for organization and responsiveness

What reviews say by service

Bankruptcy Law (Chapter 7 & 13)
Mixed: praised for fast discharge process; one client waited months for responses and eventually dropped case.
Real Estate & Property Law
Limited mention. One estate litigation case praised; another criticized for filing in wrong county.
Debt Collection & Consumer Defense
No clear evidence from reviews.
Foreclosure Defense Litigation
No clear evidence from reviews.

How it compares

  • Rated 4.4 against a 4.48 average across the 28 bankruptcy law (chapter 7 & 13) businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 93% of the businesses in this directory.

How did this business earn its score?

Ranking Method
Star rating 62
Review volume 98
Review recency 100
Review sentiment 48
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
149
4
7
3
3
2
1
1
23

Questions people ask

Is there a free consultation?
Yes, the directory lists free consultation as a service.
Who should I ask for if I need family law help?
Dustin Butler is specifically praised in multiple reviews for family law and divorce cases, though assign upfront and confirm he is handling your file.
What areas does the firm serve?
The firm states it serves Cape Coral, Fort Myers, Naples, and Southwest Florida, with attorneys available across Lee and Collier counties.

Similar foreclosure attorneys nearby

McCullough Legal Services - Cape Coral
52 low data

McCullough Legal Services - Cape Coral

5.0(2)✓ Google-verified

Two five-star reviews support this firm's work in real estate and related legal services. Limited review detail prevents deeper assessment of specific strengths.

Real Estate & Property LawFree ConsultationForeclosure Defense Litigation
Law Firm of Raymond Mitchell
71 low data

Law Firm of Raymond Mitchell

5.0(6)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

All six reviewers gave five stars. People value Raymond Mitchell's direct answers to complex legal questions, his willingness to take time on difficult cases, and the fact that he charges no fee for initial consultations. Clients hired him for bankruptcy, divorce, and complex judgment matters, and report he communicated throughout.

Debt Collection & Consumer DefenseReal Estate & Property LawFree Consultation
Orr Law Firm, P.L.
73 low data

Orr Law Firm, P.L.

5.0(12)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Clients describe Doug Orr as genuinely invested, dropping personal plans to meet urgent filing deadlines and staying available throughout matters. The small firm size means cases get personal attention rather than fluff, with clear strategy and honest, grounded communication.

Free ConsultationForeclosure Defense Litigation

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-09-27