Cape Coral Metro Foreclosure Attorney Guide
Menu
Get a case review Call

Mahshie & DeCosta, P.A.

Updated 2026-09-27 · 3,170 reviewed · 116 listed · Scored from 10 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.0(10) 56 low data composite score See reviews on Google
Foreclosure Defense LitigationReal Estate & Property LawFree ConsultationDebt Collection & Consumer Defense
Mahshie & DeCosta, P.A.
Location
Fort Myers
Services
Foreclosure Defense Litigation, Real Estate & Property Law, Free Consultation
Reviews
10
Best for
homeowners navigating complex real estate disputes or foreclosure defense

Google Business Profile is the source for the business data shown here, last checked 2026-09-27. Details taken from their website were fetched 2026-08-27.

What reviewers think

Strong counsel on real estate matters with attorneys who prioritize client interests and explain complex issues clearly. Two negative reviews cite staff rudeness and a $300 consultation fee, though most reviewers praise responsiveness and ethical guidance.

Based on limited recent reviews, so treat this as low-confidence.

Praised for
  • knowledgeable attorneys
  • client interest prioritized over fees
  • responsive and timely
  • caring and compassionate staff
Watch-outs
  • rude front desk staff
  • consultation fees
  • poor phone communication
knowledgeableresponsive-communicationprofessional-stafftransparent-feespoor-communication
Best for: homeowners navigating complex real estate disputes or foreclosure defense
Think twice if: you expect free initial consultations; one reviewer reported a $300 consultation fee.

Strengths

  • real estate expertise for complex matters
  • attorney-client interest alignment
  • punctual and timely responses

Worth knowing

  • Attorney Chris DeCosta praised for ethical guidance and attention to detail
  • Legal assistant Paige noted for compassionate client support
  • Front desk staff member Rosie cited in poor interaction
  • Calls scheduled at specified times are kept on time

What reviews say by service

Foreclosure Defense Litigation
Limited review evidence; website claims foreclosure services.
Real Estate & Property Law
Praised for handling complex real estate matters with attention to detail and client protection.

How it compares

  • Rated 4 against a 4.56 average across the 81 real estate & property law businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 40% of the businesses in this directory.

How did this business earn its score?

Ranking Method
Star rating 62
Review volume 45
Review recency 25
Review sentiment 50
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
7
4
0
3
1
2
0
1
2

Questions people ask

Do they charge for an initial consultation?
One reviewer reported a $300 fee to determine if the firm would take their case. Confirm current policy directly.
Will they return calls promptly?
Multiple reviewers confirm calls are answered or returned quickly, and scheduled meetings begin on time.
Request a quote

Similar foreclosure attorneys nearby

McIntyre & Bermudez, PLLC
80

McIntyre & Bermudez, PLLC

4.9(29)✓ Google-verified

Clients consistently praise named attorneys Reinaldo Rodriguez, Victor Bermudez, and Garrett McIntyre for thorough guidance, responsiveness, and genuine care. Victor earns particular mention for accessibility (direct phone and text) and business law expertise. One recent complaint highlights that a receptionist was unwelcoming and rates were not clearly stated before consultation.

Foreclosure Defense LitigationReal Estate & Property LawFree Consultation
View profile
The Dellutri Law Group, PA
89

The Dellutri Law Group, PA

4.9(882)✓ Google-verified

Amanda Downing and the team consistently earn praise for walking clients through accident claims, answering questions promptly, and staying in touch as cases move forward. Staff including Isaac Roman, Lauren Rush, Carmen, Juan, Nathalie, and Eli García draw specific mention for kindness and efficiency. One recent reviewer reported a week of silence after paying for a consultation, forcing them to seek elsewhere for an urgent matter. Named attorneys and paralegals handle personal injury, car accidents, bankruptcy, and foreclosure matters across Fort Myers and beyond. The firm's website notes they have served Florida since 1998 and claim to cover the entire state.

Foreclosure Defense LitigationDebt Collection & Consumer DefenseFree Consultation
View profile
Dryden Thomas M Pl
61 low data

Dryden Thomas M Pl

4.4(7)

Five reviewers praised Dryden for solving tough real estate disputes, helping clients out of bad contracts, and handling estate advice with compassion. One unhappy client cited inefficiency, unclear writing, and moments when the lawyer said he would need to research basic procedure questions.

Real Estate & Property LawForeclosure Defense Litigation
View profile

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-09-27